INTRODUCTION AND BRIEF DESCRIPTION

The definition of ship for the purposes of section 78.1 is provided in this subsection.

SECTION WORDING

78.1(5) In this section, "ship" means every description of vessel not permanently attached to the seabed, other than a warship, a ship being used as a naval auxiliary or for customs or police purposes or a ship that has been withdrawn from navigation or is laid up.

EXPLANATION

Section 78.1(5) of the Criminal Code of Canada defines the term "ship" for the purpose of the section that relates to acts of piracy. The definition includes every type of vessel that is not permanently attached to the seabed and is not a warship, a ship being used for naval auxiliary or customs or police purposes, or a ship that is withdrawn from navigation or laid up. The section criminalizes acts of piracy, which entails acts committed on the high seas that are directed against a ship, aircraft, or persons on board. The section makes it an offense to commit piracy, attempt to commit piracy, or aid or abet piracy. It also covers conspiring to commit piracy, inciting or encouraging piracy, or attempting to incite or encourage piracy. The offense carries a maximum punishment of life imprisonment. The definition of "ship" under section 78.1(5) is important because it helps to determine the scope of the offense. The section only covers acts committed against ships that fall within the definition of a "ship" under the section. Therefore, it is essential to understand the definition of "ship" to determine if a particular vessel falls within the scope of the offense. Moreover, the term "ship" is defined in a way that excludes warships, ships being used for naval auxiliary or customs or police purposes, or ships that are withdrawn from navigation or laid up. This is because these types of vessels are under the protection of the law, and acts committed against them are covered under other sections of the Criminal Code. Therefore, the exclusion of these types of vessels from the definition of "ship" ensures that the section only covers acts committed against vulnerable vessels that are not otherwise covered by the law. In conclusion, the definition of "ship" under section 78.1(5) is crucial in understanding the scope of the offense of piracy under the Criminal Code of Canada. It sets out which vessels are covered by the section and which are exempted, ensuring that the section is precisely targeted at the intended offenses it seeks to prosecute.

COMMENTARY

Section 78.1(5) of the Criminal Code of Canada classifies the term ship" and provides an outline of what it constitutes. It defines a ship as any vessel that is not permanently attached to the seabed, and excludes warships, ships used as naval auxiliary or for customs and police purposes, a retired ship that is not in use or is laid up. This definition is crucial in understanding the scope of the Section and applying it to different cases. The law recognizes that ships are movable assets, and they can be a critical means of transport and commerce. However, they are also subject to various criminal activities such as piracy, drug trafficking, smuggling, and human trafficking, which affect international security and economic stability. Therefore, the law seeks to prevent and deter these criminal activities by providing a legal framework that is clear and specific. In Section 78.1 of the Criminal Code, allegations for offences committed on ships are prosecuted in Canada regardless of the nationality of the offender or the flag of the vessel involved, provided that there is a significant connection to Canada (subsection 78.1(1)). The section further clarifies that offences in relation to ships and aircraft are either indictable or summary convictions, and the punishment can range from imprisonment to a fine (subsection 78.1(2)). The punishment depends on the severity of the offence and the nature of the law that the offender violated. Furthermore, Section 78.1(5) provides a definition of the term "ship," which is instrumental in determining the scope of the law in prosecuting offences committed on ships. The definition extends beyond just commercial ships to any movable watercraft that is not permanently anchored to the seabed. This means that cruise ships, yachts, fishing boats, pleasure crafts, and even pontoons, among others, are considered ships under the Criminal Code. However, the definition also excludes certain ships, such as warships, ships used as naval auxiliary, or for customs and police purposes, and retired ships that are not in use. This exclusion signifies that ships involved in the defense, and safety of a country are excluded from prosecution under this legislation. Moreover, a retired ship that is not being used for any purpose is also included in the exclusion. In conclusion, Section 78.1(5) of the Criminal Code provides a broad definition of a ship, which is crucial in prosecuting offences committed on a vessel not permanently attached to the seabed. It includes different types of watercraft under the term 'ship.' However, it acknowledges that some ships perform critical functions such as defense, customs, and police, which are excluded from prosecution under this legislation. The law recognizes the impact of criminal activities committed on ships on international security and economic stability, and therefore, provides a legal framework to prevent and deter these activities. The broad definition of ships under the legislation ensures that all vessels are held accountable for the offences committed on board, making it easier to prosecute those responsible.

STRATEGY

Section 78.1(5) of the Criminal Code of Canada defines the term "ship" for the purpose of the broader section that deals with offences committed on-board ships. This section is particularly pertinent for law enforcement agencies, the judiciary, and legal professionals who deal with ship-related crimes. Some strategic considerations when dealing with this section of the Criminal Code of Canada are: 1. Jurisdictional questions: The definition of a "ship" under section 78.1(5) is essential when determining whether Canadian jurisdiction applies to a vessel. For instance, if a crime occurs on a ship that is permanently attached to the seabed, Canadian law may not apply. Alternatively, if a ship is used for military or police purposes, or is not currently in use, then it may be exempt from Canadian jurisdiction. Understanding this definition is critical to ensuring that the appropriate legal authority is applied to a particular case. 2. Identification of the vessel in question: To apply section 78.1(5), it is crucial to identify the specific vessel on which the alleged crime occurred. In some cases, this may be simple, such as when an offence happened on a commercial ship with a unique name and registration number. In other situations, the identification of a ship may be more challenging. For instance, if a crime occurs on a fishing boat without proper documentation, determining the identity of that vessel may require additional investigation. Law enforcement agencies need to have the tools and training necessary to identify different kinds of ships and their associated documentation. 3. Collaborative approach: Investigating ship-related crimes requires collaboration among different law enforcement agencies and other stakeholders such as coast guards, port authorities, and maritime organizations. A collaborative approach is essential to ensure that investigations are thorough and that all relevant information is collected. A strategic collaboration hub could identify the right stakeholders, procedures, and communication channels needed for effective investigation and prosecution of offences committed on board ships. 4. Failure to comply with international maritime laws: Ships in international waters fall under different jurisdictions and international maritime laws. These maritime laws have been designed to protect human life, the marine environment, and traffic safety. If a Canadian ship does not comply with these international regulations, it may be subjected to prosecution in international courts, which can be lengthy and expensive. Therefore, ensuring compliance with international maritime regulations and safety protocols is crucial in mitigating the risk of such prosecutions and defending one's position. 5. Conflict-of-laws issues: Section 78.1(5) covers only national laws applicable to ships making it important to consider the effect of foreign governing legal regimes when determining the applicable law. Moreover, in cases where two different countries have an issue regarding a ship that has crossed their borders, the court may be required to apply conflict of law's principle to determine which law to apply. Strategies to address these concerns should include the application of proper legal instruments, such as international treaties and conventions, to regulate activities on board ships that pass through different states. Strategies that could be employed in dealing with this section of the Criminal Code of Canada include training Law enforcement agencies on ship identification and documentation, data sharing and collaborative procedures between stakeholders, compliance with international maritime regulations and procedures, lobbying for international laws' harmonization, and incorporating conflict of law principles in the agreement and treaty negotiation. Other strategies include providing additional funding resources and involving experts in the maritime industry who can provide insight into various aspects of ships and offences committed on them. Finally, creating specialized maritime courts and procedures may facilitate the adjudication of matters related to the sea.

CATEGORIES